This is for an overcoat, something with thick layers of fabric. You can skip the raising and wrapping the thread around underneath for a shirt.
18 steps? What am I, unemployed?
Not anymore. You can be a tailor’s apprentice with this knowledge
Time to engage in sartorial pursuits!
Nah just shove it through in random patterns like a hundred times. It works well enough.
This is the way
What a fantastic community I’ve discovered. Thank you for this nugget of knowledge.
I’m sure this is probably useful and makes sense in some way, but it’s really giving me rest of the fucking owl energy. I just can’t follow it clearly after like step 9 or so.
Step 8. The toothpick is used to loosen the loops and make distance between the button and the fabric. This is necessay. The button would be too tight to function properly otherwise.
Step 9 is to remove the toothpick and sew upwards under the button, but not through the button.
Steps 10-12. Since the sewing isn’t tightened down, you’ll need to secure it by wrapping the string around it a couple of times. (This is why you don’t sew through the button in step 9).
Steps 13-rest. Sew through the existing loops and tie a knot to secure the thread.
I’ve always done it like up to step 7, then finishing it, and it’s been fine for shirts and some pants - but I guess the extra steps do make sense for thicker fabrics.
Yes, it won’t make much difference to a shirt, but it’s necessary for a blazer or outerwear, where the fabric is thicker and the button is getting pulled a lot more.
I was following along quite nicely until step 9, where you bank-shot the needle off Mars and simultaneously looped it under the button.
I think the toothpick or whatever is to put space while keeping the thread tight? So that when you lift the button everything is still tight and all you have to do is wrap under. The drawing is… not clear.
Oh man I thought that was the needle, not a toothpick. Suddenly this makes sense.
The toothpick is to provide spacing for the button, then you pull it out as you wrap the thread around underneath it.
Hah, this reminds me of when I had to write repair manuals in college. I’d get so fixated on a particular tool, like a toothpick. I’d start by saying, “I’m definitely going to need this toothpick.”
by the end I probably didn’t even need it, but I included it anyway.
Yes, basically you want (because this is from a jeans company) to create a shank under the button, lifting it enough to fit thick fabric, but evenly so the button sits flat on top!
“You can’t just sew a button onto the surface of mars” - Samuel Hayden
Does it have to be sponsored though?
In the future, everything is brought to you by a corporation. Even your dreams! Have a pleasant day! (Sponsored by Eli Lilly)
For the confused: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UNPVqbgEUCU
Perfect, I need to move a button on my jacket.
I’m sorry but this is way too complicated for what it is. I don’t care about logistics, this is a thing that should be able to be done in 8 steps instead of 18.
How would you do it in 8 steps, then?
1,5,6,7,5,6,7,make a knot.
I usually repeat 5,6,7 until I am out of thread.
Wise guy, eh? First I’d do it in 8 steps and then be done with it.
Ah yes, the “draw the rest of the owl” technique. I know it well!
Username checks out.
Cut off the buttons and sew on a zipper.
Nice. I prefer a nice pearl snap shirt myself. Now I need a snap riveter… Thanks.
That is significantly more complicated than how I was taught to sew in a button. Is this just for big metal buttons on jeans or something? It seems massively over the top for normal shirt buttons, which come off fairly regularly.
Roughly what I was taught (for a 4 hole button, in a “cross” shape):
- Shove threaded needle through material into hole in button
- Go across diagonally and go down through the opposite hole and through the material
- Under the material, go across sideways a bit and come up in a different hole
- Repeat 1-3 a bunch of times until it feels strong enough.
- Tie off the thread and cut off the excess.
The part about wrapping around the treads between the button and shirt is to give space for the button hole side and to protect the threads from wearing against the button hole and provide longevity to the repair.
Yeah, it totally makes sense for some uses.
normal shirt buttons, which come off fairly regularly.
Maybe your technique isn’t sufficient and the posted method isn’t as “over the top” as you claim, but fundamental to not loosing buttons.
Sorry I wasn’t clear about that - my replaced ones have never come off again - it’s the original ones on the shirt which tend to.
[Edit] Note that I am always wearing a shirt, and much of my work is manual/technical, so mine perhaps get knocked off a bit more frequently than others might.
Stop trying to make me self sufficient. I don’t wanna do all that work.
I think I’m stuck at 0. What kind of knot is used to keep both ends of the thread together?
The european death knot usually works pretty well. Or you could use a weaver’s knot, but it’s not as bulky. The ‘overhand’ family of knots is a pretty good bet for whenever you want a knot that absolutely will not come untied under tension.
I honestly double the thread up so that it’s a little tougher and then I just tie a regular knot at the end, but a few times. Hide the knots and you’re good.
I don’t knot the thread like in the picture. I anchor it into the fabric.
1 - Pass the thread through the fabric once, leaving a short tail. 2 - Pass it through the same spot to form a loop, keeping that tail from step 1. 3 - Pass it through the loop, but not all the way to form a second loop. 4 - Hold the tail, pull the second loop to tighten the first loop down to the fabric. 5 - Pass your thread through the second loop and tighten down to the fabric. (Sometimes I do a third loop before this step, but not always.) You have now anchored your thread.
Step 17 looks like a microcosm of me cable managing a PC
“What am I gonna do with all these extra cable bits? Oh right, same thing I do every time, jumble it up and stuff it in the bottom!”
Also, this feels like, unnecessarily complicated. Million dollar idea: button staples. Shoot a couple pointy bits through the diagonal holes, it attaches itself on the back somehow (that’s for engineers to work out, I’m just the idea man), repeat on the other diagonal, bam, button attached.
https://www.amazon.com/Buttoneer-Button-Fastening-System-Necessary/dp/B09MR8GZR9
I’m including an Amazon link because I can’t imagine anyone actually following my comment and buying this piece of shit, but if it helps: don’t give Bezos money.
I just bought 2 dozen for my sweatshop 👍👍👍
Now I just need some lawyers to file some post-facto patents Nintendo style and collect my money
It has the number of steps it does so that the pressure from the button holding your pants closed is evenly distributed over the fabric (and thread), so that nothing tears or rips. When sewing through cloth more points of attachment is generally better. You might be able to staple a button on without damaging the fabric over time, but it’s probably a lot less comfortable to wear than one sewn on.
Just attached a button to my pants yesterday, after the factory sewn button gave up.
